| Platinum | Napoli Pizzeria |
| Gold | Pietro's No. 2 Ristorante, Bar & Lounge |
| Silver | Fuso |
| Bronze | Cenario's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Amici's East Coast Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | La Borgata Italian Deli |
| Top Pick | Mäksē Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mary's Pizza Shack |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |